Asuu

Who pays for prevention?

The cost comes now, and the benefit arrives decades later, often to a different insurer. Few systems are built to wait.

Open question. Not yet tested.

On this page

Why it is hard.

Prevention is paid for now and pays back in thirty years. In a system built on insurance, the person will by then have a different insurer, because people change jobs every few years and their cover changes with them. The company that paid to keep you well has, in effect, made a gift to a competitor.

Governments could take the long view and mostly do not, because budgets are annual and prevention is invisible when it works. Nobody holds a ceremony for the heart attack that did not happen.

What has been tried.

Public-health funding, tobacco and sugar taxes, workplace programmes, and outcome-based financing approach prevention in different ways. Some already reward measured outcomes. The question is whether an Asuu arrangement could fairly attribute a benefit, identify who paid for it, and avoid rewarding a misleading measure.

A direction we would test.

We would test two ideas. The first is membership for life. A mutual that a person stays in through every job and every country is one where the payer who invests in a thirty-year-old is still the payer when she is sixty.

The second is a prevention ledger. Football has a rule that when a young player is sold, the club that trained him as a boy receives a share of the fee. A record of preventive care, and of what followed, could do the same between insurers: when a member moves, the one that kept her well is credited by the one that inherits a healthy member.

Nobody holds a ceremony for the heart attack that did not happen.

How we would know we were wrong.

It may prove impossible to show that an illness was avoided because of something done years earlier. If the credit cannot be calculated in a way both insurers accept, or if it rewards recording activity more than improving health, the ledger is an accounting fiction.

Who could solve it.

A health economist. An actuary who can say whether credit for a healthy member could be calculated in a way two insurers would both accept. Someone who has run a mutual or a cooperative for decades. And a public health official who has had to defend a prevention budget in a room full of people looking for savings.

Where this connects.

Solve one with us.

Tell us which problem you work on, and what we have got wrong about it.