Asuu

Objections

The case against Asuu.

Anyone proposing something this large should be able to argue against it. These are the strongest objections we know. Some of them we cannot yet answer.

The ambition

Too much, too soon.

“It is far too broad.”

As a list, yes. That is why there is an order. The Network is in development. Each later stage depends on evidence, people, and the work before it.

See how Asuu grows

“One founder, still in training, cannot build this.”

He cannot, alone. The purpose of this site is to bring together people with the judgement and experience the work needs. An institution meant to outlive its founder has to stop depending on him early.

Read Article VI

“None of this exists.”

The papers and the Network work in development are the starting point. The assistant, companies, and services are proposed. Each is described here so people can examine the ambition and help decide what deserves to be built.

Read the papers

The technology

More machines in medicine.

“Medicine does not need more AI.”

It is arriving regardless. The question is whether anyone can see which model acted and who approved it. That is the part we are building first.

Explore Asuu Network

“A lifelong record is a lifelong risk.”

It is. One record is one target, and one point of misuse. We have not solved this, and we say so.

See the open problems

“People will trust it too much.”

Some will. The assistant is meant to say what it does not know and when to see a person, but good manners do not guarantee good judgement in the reader.

Read the rules of conduct

Trust

Why you, and why a company.

“Governments already keep national records.”

They do, and Asuu should connect to them. What a national system rarely offers is a record that crosses a border, or one for an animal or a field.

“A company cannot be trusted with this.”

Probably not on its word. Hence a foundation for the open project, a charter published before there is anything to sell, and a promise that the record is never for sale.

See who pays

“Institutions will not share.”

Often true. We do not yet know what would make sharing worth it to them. It is one of our open problems.

See the open problems

The living world

A step too far.

“Animals and farms are a distraction.”

For a decade they may be. But resistance to antibiotics ignores the boundary between a hospital and a farm, and a design that ignores it would have to be rebuilt later.

Read about the mission

Make the case better than we have.

If we have missed the strongest objection, we would like to hear it from you first.