How does an institution stay honest as it grows?
Most commitments, such as those in the charter, are made when an organisation is small. We do not know how to make them hold when it is large.
Open question. Not yet tested.
On this page
Why it is hard.
Every promise in the charter was written when Asuu was one person and a set of papers. Promises are cheap at that size. They become expensive when there are investors to answer, lawyers to consult, and a competitor doing well by breaking the same rules.
Founders also leave, and missions drift without anyone deciding that they should. A company can keep its slogan on the wall for years after it has stopped meaning it.
What has been tried.
Some of the oldest industrial companies in Europe are owned by foundations that hold the purpose and cannot sell it. Other firms adopt legal forms that bind directors to a public benefit, or give a guardian a share with a veto. Professions regulate themselves. All of these help. None has made an institution honest that did not want to be.
A direction we would test.
We would make each promise checkable by a stranger and costly to break. Every article of the charter gets a test that someone outside Asuu can run. The yearly almanac reports the results and is reviewed by people Asuu does not pay, including patients who hold a seat where decisions are made.
Then tripwires. A change to the charter would require a long public notice and the agreement of the foundation. A venture that cannot meet its conditions is closed, in public. And beneath everything sits the right to leave. If people can take their records and go, an institution that breaks its word loses them.
How we would know we were wrong.
An almanac nobody reads disciplines nobody. If the first editions pass without a single outside challenge, or if a tripwire is ever amended quietly because it had become inconvenient, the system has failed in exactly the way it was built to prevent.
Who could solve it.
Someone who has sat on the board of a company owned by a foundation. A lawyer who has drafted a purpose that survived a change of owners, or watched one fail. A journalist or an auditor used to reading what an organisation would prefer not to publish. And former employees of places that lost their way, who know how it began.
Where this connects.
Solve one with us.
Tell us which problem you work on, and what we have got wrong about it.