What does consent mean for someone who cannot give it?
An infant, a person with dementia, an animal, a herd. A genome also describes relatives who were never asked.
Open question. Not yet tested.
On this page
Why it is hard.
Consent was designed for one situation: a capable adult deciding about their own body. Much of care happens outside it. A newborn decides nothing. A man with advanced dementia decided things once and cannot now. A dog, a herd, and a field never will.
Genetics breaks the model in another way. Your genome is half your mother's and half your father's, and it says a good deal about your children. In 2018 police in California identified a murderer because distant relatives of his had uploaded their DNA to a genealogy site. He had never agreed to anything. One person's consent had disclosed a family.
What has been tried.
The law offers guardians, powers of attorney, and the test of a person's best interests. Paediatrics adds assent, asking a child's agreement even where it is not legally required. Some research biobanks practise dynamic consent, returning to donors as new uses arise. Each is a patch on a model built around the individual.
A direction we would test.
We would stop recording consent as a single yes and record three things in its place: who decided, on what authority, and until when. A parent decides for a child, on the authority of being her parent, until she is old enough to decide herself. Every decision made on someone's behalf would carry an expiry date, after which it must be reviewed or handed over.
For a person who could once decide, their earlier wishes would outrank the wishes of anyone speaking for them now. For genomes, a relative could register in advance that they do not want to be told what someone else’s result implies about them.
Agreement given by someone else should always have an end date.
How we would know we were wrong.
If stewards treat each review as a box to tick, the expiry date becomes ceremony. If reviews are missed and care is interrupted because an authority lapsed on a Tuesday, the cure is worse than the disease. Either result in a pilot would send us back to the start.
Who could solve it.
A paediatrician, a psychiatrist of old age, a veterinarian, and a lawyer who works on guardianship rarely sit at one table, and this problem needs all four. So does anyone who has had to decide for a parent who could no longer decide, and has wondered since whether they chose as the parent would have.
Where this connects.
Solve one with us.
Tell us which problem you work on, and what we have got wrong about it.