How can a person hold their own record without being able to lose it?
If only the person holds the key, one lost phone erases a lifetime. If an institution holds it, the record is no longer theirs.
Open question. Not yet tested.
On this page
Why it is hard.
There are two honest ways to hold a record, and each breaks. If the person alone holds the key, the record is truly theirs, and one lost phone or one forgotten password erases a lifetime. Millions of bitcoin are thought to be out of reach for ever for exactly this reason, and their owners were people who cared a great deal about not losing them.
Institutional custody can provide recovery arrangements, but it does not remove the possibility of loss, compromise, or misuse. It also leaves the person dependent on the institution’s rules and continuity. A recovery design must work when someone is ill, frightened, or far from home.
What has been tried.
Email resets are convenient and weak. Banks check identity in person, which is slow and fails across borders. In 1979 the cryptographer Adi Shamir showed how to split a secret among several people so that only a chosen number of them, acting together, can rebuild it. Some digital wallets now use the idea and call it social recovery. Medicine has not tried it.
A direction we would test.
We would test recovery through the people who already share in someone's care. A person names five: perhaps a partner, a daughter, a family doctor's practice, a close friend, a notary. Each holds a fragment that is useless alone. Any three together can restore access. None of them can read the record by holding a fragment.
Two safeguards matter as much as the mathematics. Every recovery waits a few days and tells the owner by every route available, so that a quiet takeover has time to be noticed. And every recovery is written into the record itself: who asked, who helped, and when.
How we would know we were wrong.
The people most at risk are those with nobody to name. If a trial with older adults who live alone shows that they cannot assemble a circle, the idea protects the fortunate and fails the rest. It also fails if a team paid to attack it can talk three guardians into helping a stranger.
Who could solve it.
Someone who designs how keys are kept and recovered. A geriatrician or a social worker who knows what older people living alone can and cannot manage. A lawyer who understands what a notary or a family doctor may lawfully hold on a person's behalf. And anyone who has been locked out of something that mattered, and remembers exactly how it felt.
Where this connects.
Solve one with us.
Tell us which problem you work on, and what we have got wrong about it.